LCTRLocal-comparison theory of time reference

Analysis & proof sources

Incomplete thermal flows and thermal-clock existenceOn equations (17)–(18) of Forget time

Comment paper: Forget time

Naoaki Tsuda

tsuda.naoaki@gmail.com · 13 October 2026

Documents

Detailed analysis PDF · Questions PDF

Browse Isabelle proof sources · Download proof archive (ZIP)

Record and citation: doi:10.5281/zenodo.23320911

The sections below identify the relevant results in the detailed analysis and their proof sources. Page numbers are the numbers printed in the PDF.

Q1

Does the counterexample to Eq. (18) affect the measured-time existence claim?

Locations in the detailed analysis
TopicDetailed analysis PDF
sufficient conditions for the full-state correlationProposition 7, p. 21
clock correspondence required by the measured-time assertion§10.2, p. 27
finite entropy, every polynomial position--momentum moment and realizations on the reduced phase spaces of complete constrained systems§6, p. 20
a family of positive normalized counterexamplesProposition 6, p. 20
the normalized counterexampleTheorem 1, p. 17
the zero-probability set of complete trajectoriesProposition 4, p. 18

Machine-checked results

Smoothness, positivity and normalization of the counterexample density; the coordinate transformation and probability measure; the maximal solution interval; and positive probability of the set where the flow is undefined at each nonzero parameter.

§22.1, p. 56

Q2

Do the different correlations obtained by completing the flow affect the interpretation of Eq. (18)?

Locations in the detailed analysis
TopicDetailed analysis PDF
compact-support stationarityProposition 10, p. 24
two invariant completionsProposition 11, p. 24
the strictly positive difference between their correlationsEq. 29, p. 25

Machine-checked results

Probability preservation, the group laws and local agreement for the periodic and reflecting completions, together with a positive lower bound on their correlation difference for the same bounded measurable observables.

§22.1, p. 57

Q3

What correspondence with physical clock readings is intended in the thermal-clock existence claim?

Locations in the detailed analysis
TopicDetailed analysis PDF
correspondence for a restricted family of observables§1.2, p. 3
information loss in records and apparatus-dependent validity domains§1.3, p. 3
the chosen clock's observable family and measurement equality§10.2, p. 27
the constant-recalibration criterion and successive repairs§10.3, p. 28
the obstruction to a global affine clock on stationary probability space§10.5, p. 30
a complete thermal flow tested against the original motions and a conserved observable§10.4, p. 29

Machine-checked results

The relation between correlation agreement and agreement of readings; the correspondence between constant calibration and Gibbs form; the obstruction to a global affine clock; estimation bounds arising from information loss in records and finite sampling; and admissible scales that depend on apparatus performance.

§22.1, p. 57

Q4

Does the obstruction to the classical correlation bear on a quantum modular justification?

Locations in the detailed analysis
TopicDetailed analysis PDF
quantum support for equation (18) and its clock interpretation§8.3, p. 23
the additional clock-measurement correspondence§10.2, p. 27

Machine-checked results

A correlation-error bound derived from the separate error estimates connecting quantum evolution, classical correlations and clock measurements.

§22.1, p. 57

Q5

What does state-based time recovery propose to construct concerning clocks, dynamics and order?

Locations in the detailed analysis
TopicDetailed analysis PDF
the clock correspondence in Q3§10.2, p. 27
replacement, withdrawal and return to earlier grounds§2.7, p. 8
limits of repairs retaining circular dependence§2.9, p. 10
inputs and outputs of the recovery construction in Forget time§10.1, p. 26
rescaling and the conditions inherited by the 2024 prescription§11.1, p. 31
tracing the grounds of clock readings§2.1, p. 5
a model establishing clock correspondence through comparisons of physical indications and records§19.2, p. 44

Machine-checked results

Persistence of the Q1 obstruction under nonzero constant rescaling, and circular dependence and reachability in finite inference systems with premise substitutions and alternative derivations.

§22.1, p. 57

Proof verification

The proof sources build with Isabelle2025-2. The proof guide gives the build command and the correspondence between Questions 1–5 and the formal results. The verification record lists the checked results and source-file hashes.

Formalized assumptions and their relation to the mathematical argument: §22.1, p. 56